http://finance.yahoo.com/news/Nokia-lodges-another-apf-1124893682.html?x=0
Nokia files another lawsuit against Apple over technology patents
Andrew Vanacore, AP Business Writer,
NEW YORK (AP) — Finnish cell phone maker Nokia Corp. said Friday that it has extended its patent-infringement claims against Apple Inc. to include the new iPad.
The latest complaint, filed in U.S. District Court in Madison, Wis., follows other lawsuits by Nokia claiming that a broad swath of Apple products violate Nokia patents. Nokia says the disputed technologies help reduce the size and cost of electronic gadgets. Apple had already responded with its own infringement claims against Nokia.
Lawsuits over patent rights are common in the technology industry. They can take years to resolve and often end with some kind of licensing agreement. In the meantime, consumers should be able to buy the Apple or Nokia products in question.
Apple has also sued Taiwan’s HTC Corp., one of the leading producers of cell phones that run on Google Inc.’s Android software, a potential challenger to Apple’s popular iPhone. Apple says HTC’s Android phones violate iPhone patents.
The legal disputes come amid increasing competition in the fast-growing market for smart phones. Tech companies are scrambling to win over the growing number of consumers buying cell phones that come with e-mail, Web surfing and scores of apps for checking the weather, updating Facebook and other tasks.
Nokia is the world’s biggest cell phone maker, though it is more dominant in Asia and Europe. In the U.S., it faces intense competition from the iPhone and Research in Motion Ltd.’s BlackBerrys.
Nokia’s latest lawsuit targets the iPhone and the iPad 3G, the version of the device that can connect to the Web using cell phone networks. Nokia said the gadgets infringe on five patents related to technology that makes voice and data communications more efficient, which allows the devices to be more compact.
"We have taken this step to protect the results of our pioneering development and to put an end to continued unlawful use of Nokia’s innovation," Nokia executive Paul Melin said in a statement.
Apple spokesman Steve Dowling declined to comment on the new case but said the company had already filed a countersuit in December to earlier claims by Nokia. Apple claims Nokia is infringing on 13 of its patents, saying the company chose to "copy the iPhone" in order to recapture its share of the high-end phone market.
Apple shares fell $10.39, or 4.2 percent, to $235.86 Friday on a day of market turbulence following some of the most volatile trading in history on Thursday afternoon. Nokia shares rose 9 cents to $10.75.
Nokia Sues Apple Over iPad
http://www.pcworld.com/article/195862/nokia_sues_apple_over_ipad.html
Nokia claims both the iPhone and iPad violate five patents held by the electronics company.
Ed Oswald , Technologizer
Nokia has just announced that it has sued Apple in Federal District Court in the Western District of Wisconsin, claiming that both the iPad and iPhone violate five patents held by the electronics maker.
"The patents in question relate to technologies for enhanced speech and data transmission, using positioning data in applications and innovations in antenna configurations that improve performance and save space, allowing smaller and more compact devices," according to a statement from the company.
Although the wording is of course somewhat vague, the suit appears to hit the heart of what has made applications on the iPad and iPhone what they are. Positioning data in applications has become a central feature — most of the major ones carry some type of location-aware technology.
I’m not sure what Nokia means by "enhanced speech and data transmission," and have asked the company to clarify exactly what those specific patents do cover.
Nokia’s suit surely comes as a surprise to the tech community, as it had not publicly made any indication that it believed its intellectual property rights had been violated. That said, it’s not the first suit between the two companies: a suit last year involved GSM, UMTS, and Wi-Fi standards. A request for comment has been sent to Apple, however no response has been received as of press time. Also, Apple has sued HTC for patent infringement. (See also "7 Patent Lawsuits That Affect Your Tech.")
